Why do maternal mortality rates vary so much in the States?

Why do maternal mortality rates vary so much in the States?
Photo by Ömürden Cengiz / Unsplash

A woman giving birth in Tennessee faces close to four times the risk of dying from pregnancy-related causes as a woman giving birth in California. That gap, larger than the gap between the United States and many of its wealthy peers, is evidence that maternal death in America is not one national problem but fifty state-level ones.

Nationally, the picture has improved since the pandemic. The U.S. maternal mortality rate peaked at 32.9 deaths per 100,000 live births in 2021, then fell to 18.6 in 2023, and 17.9 in 2024, according to the Congressional Research Service.

That is a look at bird’s eye view. Look closer, and non-Hispanic Black women died at a rate of 44.8 per 100,000 in 2024, more than double the national rate.

Why it Matters

Most of these deaths should not happen. But the risks—and the resources available to women—vary dramatically depending on where they live. Each death leaves a newborn, often older children, and a partner or extended family to carry on without her.

The risks also reach families who survive. Women in maternity care deserts travel about three times as far to give birth. In an August report, the March of Dimes links longer travel to later prenatal care, more serious complications, and added costs for transportation, childcare, lodging, and missed work.

Coverage gaps hit household budgets too: in Arkansas, the only state without a year of postpartum Medicaid, 44% of postpartum mothers on Medicaid lost coverage in the last quarter of 2025. Postpartum care ends 60 days after birth for Medicaid patients in that state.

That is why state policy choices matter. With Medicaid paying for four of 10 U.S. births, decisions about who qualifies, for how long, and whether local hospitals keep delivering babies shape care for women and their families. Knowing which states fall short, and why, tells families and lawmakers what actions could save lives.

High and Low States

Pooling 2020 to 2024 deaths to get stable numbers, the Congressional Research Service found the national rate was 23.1 deaths per 100,000 live births. Tennessee was highest at 41.8, followed by Louisiana (39.4) and Mississippi (37.5). California was lowest at 10.8.

  • The highest-risk states are clustered in the South. Tennessee, Louisiana, and Mississippi all ran 60% to 80% above the national rate. A woman in Tennessee faced nearly four times the risk of one in California. The highest-mortality states are mostly in the South, where uninsured rates among women are highest, and maternity care deserts are common.
  • The lowest-risk states run across regions. Besides California, Hawaii, Washington, Minnesota, Connecticut, and Utah met the Healthy People 2030 target of 15.7 deaths per 100,000. They span the West Coast, Pacific, Upper Midwest, New England, and Mountain West.
  • Most states are not near the goal. Twenty-three states were above the national average of 23.1, so the national figure is supported by a broad group of states, not just a few outliers.

How does the U.S. compare globally? In 2023, the overall U.S. maternal mortality rate most resembled rates in Palestine (18.6) and Chile (18.9). At the high end on the state level, Louisiana (41.9) fell between Mexico (41.7) and the Seychelles (42.0), while California (9.5) fell between Canada (9.4) and Kazakhstan (10.0), among the lowest global rates.

Why the States Differ

Insurance coverage. Medicaid paid for 40% of U.S. births in 2024, and more than half in three states, according to KFF. Every state must cover low-income pregnant women, but what happens before and after pregnancy depends on state policy choices.

As of May 2026, 40 states and Washington, D.C., had adopted the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion. In the 10 that have not, about 576,000 poor uninsured women earn too much for Medicaid but too little for Affordable Care Act Marketplace subsidies, leaving them uninsured or with unaffordable premiums.

Nearly every state now provides 12 months of postpartum Medicaid coverage, narrowing one longstanding difference in maternal healthcare policy. But significant state differences remain in eligibility before pregnancy, broader Medicaid expansion, and access to providers.

Access to care. March of Dimes counts 34.6% of U.S. counties as maternity care deserts, with no birthing hospital, birth center, or obstetric clinician. Unfortunately, about 2.4 million women of reproductive age live in those counties. At least 96 labor and delivery units closed across 35 states between January 2024 and May 2026, adding an average of 25 minutes of travel and risk of complications. About 58% of rural counties lack an obstetric clinician, compared with 19% of urban counties.

Population health. The leading causes of pregnancy-related death are mental health conditions, including overdose and suicide (23%), hemorrhage (14%), and heart conditions (13%).

Chronic conditions raise risk before pregnancy begins. March of Dimes found pre-pregnancy hypertension rose more than 80% from 2015 to 2022 and was 1.3 times as common in maternity care deserts. These conditions, along with poverty, are more common in the Deep South states with the highest death rates.

Other state policies. Currently, only 14 states and D.C. provide mandatory paid parental leave, and at least 27 states and DC cover or are moving to cover doula care in Medicaid.

What Policy Patterns Show and What They Don't

The strongest policy evidence concerns Medicaid expansion. A 2020 study in Women’s Health Issues compared states before and after expansion from 2006 to 2017. It found expansion was associated with about 7 fewer maternal deaths per 100,000 live births, with the largest effect among Black mothers.

But Medicaid expansion can’t be considered the only answer, as state policies often intertwine.

  • Policies work together. States that skip Medicaid expansion also tend to have fewer paid-leave laws and stricter abortion rules. With so few states, it is hard to separate the effect of any one policy.
  • Underlying differences run deep. Poverty, chronic disease, rurality, and the legacy of structural racism all predate current policy and shape outcomes on their own. Population differences, including the share of Black residents, explain part of the state gaps.
  • Counterexamples exist. Louisiana expanded Medicaid in 2016 yet remains near the top. Utah has one of the lowest shares of women on Medicaid yet meets the national target.
  • Some policies no longer differ. With 12-month postpartum coverage now universal, except for Arkansas, it cannot explain today’s gaps, and its effects on deaths will take years to measure.

Where a woman lives strongly predicts her risk, and the riskiest states combine weaker coverage, thinner access to care, and sicker populations. CDC has judged most deaths preventable, and many occur after delivery, when coverage and follow-up care depend most on state choices.

Why are so many maternal deaths preventable, and what can policy do?
In the United States, most pregnancy-related deaths reviewed by maternal mortality experts are considered preventable. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 85.7% of pregnancy-related deaths reviewed in 2022 were classified as preventable. But what does preventable actually mean? It doesn't necessarily mean

Resources

Maternal Mortality Trends in the United States: Data in Brief (R49000), June 2026 - Congressional Research Service
How Do U.S. States Compare Internationally, Oct. 2025 - Commonwealth Fund, Maternal and Child Mortality
Nowhere to Go: Maternity Care Deserts Across the U.S., Aug. 2026 - March of Dimes,
2024 Maternity Care Deserts report release - March of Dimes
Medicaid Coverage for Women, Aug. 2026 - KFF
Wisconsin Passes 12-Month Postpartum Medicaid Extension, Feb. 2026 - Georgetown CCF
Factsheet, Maternal Mental Health: Policy Center for Maternal Mental Health

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Women's Rights Data Initiative.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.

Women's Rights by State

Colors reflect protections across tracked rights categories

Select your state to explore details